When Should I Claim Social Security Benefits?

Introduction

When should I claim Social Security benefits? If you’re nearing retirement, this is likely one of your top financial questions. The answer isn’t one-size-fits-all. Timing your Social Security claim can significantly impact your monthly income, overall lifetime benefits, and tax implications.

In this article, we’ll help you understand the options, considerations, and strategies so you can make a confident and informed decision about claiming your benefits.

Understanding Your Options

You can begin claiming Social Security retirement benefits as early as age 62 or as late as age 70. Your “full retirement age” (FRA) — which ranges from 66 to 67 depending on your birth year — is the baseline at which you receive your full benefits. Claiming before or after that age adjusts your monthly payout.

Delaying benefits results in “delayed retirement credits” — an incentive for waiting. But is waiting always the right move? That depends on your personal and financial circumstances.

Claiming benefits early gives you access to funds sooner, which may be necessary if you retire earlier than expected or face unforeseen expenses. On the other hand, delaying your claim can offer a form of longevity insurance, especially if you anticipate a longer life expectancy and want to secure a higher income later in life.

Key Factors to Consider

1. Life Expectancy

Your health and family history can play a major role. If you expect a longer-than-average lifespan, delaying benefits could provide greater lifetime income. If your life expectancy is shorter, claiming earlier may be more beneficial. Think about your parents’ longevity, personal medical history, and lifestyle choices.

According to the Social Security Administration, about one in three 65-year-olds today will live past age 90, and one in seven will live past age 95. That makes the decision of when to claim Social Security benefits a crucial one, especially for those planning for a long retirement.

2. Current Income Needs

Do you need the income now? If you’re retiring without other substantial income sources, claiming early might be necessary. On the other hand, if you can cover your expenses through other means — such as savings, a pension, or part-time work — delaying could result in a larger monthly benefit.

Also consider whether claiming early could lead you to spend down savings more quickly, potentially reducing your future financial flexibility.

3. Employment Status

Still working before your full retirement age? Your benefits may be temporarily reduced if your earnings exceed certain thresholds. For 2025, if you’re under full retirement age and earn more than $22,320 annually, your benefits may be reduced by $1 for every $2 earned over the limit. Once you reach FRA, there’s no penalty for working while receiving benefits.

This earnings test often leads individuals to delay benefits until they’ve stopped working or reduced their hours.

4. Spousal Benefits

Married couples have additional strategies to consider. For example, one spouse can claim a spousal benefit while the other delays their own, increasing the eventual monthly benefit. Widows and widowers also have the option to take survivor benefits first and switch to their own benefit later, or vice versa, depending on which provides the larger payout.

It’s important to coordinate benefits within a marriage to ensure both spouses receive optimal income throughout retirement and potentially enhance survivor benefits.

5. Tax Considerations

Depending on your total income, up to 85% of your Social Security benefits may be taxable. This includes income from pensions, IRAs, and part-time work. Coordinating withdrawals from retirement accounts and timing your Social Security claim can help minimize your tax burden.

You can also consider Roth conversions or strategic withdrawals before claiming Social Security to lower your taxable income in later years.

Pros and Cons of Early vs. Delayed Claiming

Claiming Early (Before FRA)

Pros:

• Receive benefits sooner
• Helpful if you need income right away
• Potentially higher lifetime benefit if you pass away earlier
• May reduce pressure to withdraw from retirement savings early

Cons:

• Permanently reduced monthly benefit (up to 30%)
• Potential earnings penalty if still working
• Less protection against longevity risk

Claiming at FRA

Pros:

• No reduction or increase — receive full benefits
• No penalty for working
• Balanced choice for many retirees
• Easier to coordinate with other retirement income sources

Cons:

• May not maximize monthly income
• Still requires strategic planning for tax and withdrawals

Claiming at Age 70

Pros:

• Maximum monthly benefit (up to 132% of full benefit)
• Greater financial security in later retirement years
• Better protection against inflation and healthcare cost increases

Cons:

• Requires other income sources until age 70
• Risk of not living long enough to benefit from higher payouts
• May require careful drawdown strategy from retirement accounts

Common Scenarios and Strategies

The “Break-Even” Analysis

This compares the total benefits you’d receive over time from claiming early vs. delaying. Typically, if you live beyond age 78-80, delaying can lead to greater total benefits. This break-even point varies by individual and depends on life expectancy, investment returns, and tax status.

Coordinated Spousal Strategies

Couples can optimize Social Security benefits by strategically choosing when each spouse claims. For example:

• The lower-earning spouse claims early
• The higher-earning spouse delays until age 70 to maximize survivor benefits

This strategy can secure a higher benefit for the surviving spouse, which may be especially important if they are expected to live much longer.

Bridging the Gap Strategy

Some retirees use savings or part-time income to delay Social Security until age 70, unlocking the highest possible monthly benefit. This approach requires discipline but may result in higher guaranteed income later on.

It’s often beneficial to spend down taxable accounts first, preserving tax-advantaged accounts and maximizing the Social Security payout.

Case Study: Sarah’s Retirement Plan

Sarah is 64 and plans to retire at 66. She asks, “When should I claim Social Security benefits?” She’s in good health, expects to live into her 90s, and has enough retirement savings to cover the next several years.

Her financial planner runs a break-even analysis and determines that waiting until 70 would increase her monthly benefit by $600 and provide over $120,000 more in lifetime income — assuming she lives past age 83.

Given her situation, Sarah decides to delay claiming and use her savings until then, ensuring greater financial security in her later years.

Her strategy also includes converting a portion of her traditional IRA to a Roth IRA over the next few years to reduce future required minimum distributions and potential tax on Social Security benefits.

So, When Should I Claim Social Security Benefits?

The answer depends entirely on your unique circumstances. You should weigh your health, income needs, spousal planning, and tax implications before making a decision. There’s no universally right answer — but there is a right answer for you.

If you’re still asking yourself, “When should I claim Social Security benefits?” — consider consulting a financial planner who can model different scenarios tailored to your goals.

Also, consider using the Social Security Administration’s online tools and calculators to estimate your benefits and understand the long-term implications of your timing decision.

Final Thoughts

Social Security is a critical piece of your retirement puzzle. The timing of your claim can affect your financial well-being for decades. Whether you choose to claim early, wait until your full retirement age, or delay until 70, the key is making an informed, strategic decision.

Take time to run the numbers, talk with your spouse or advisor, and think about your long-term needs. What works for your friend or neighbor may not be best for you.

So, the next time you wonder, “When should I claim Social Security benefits?”— remember that with the right planning, your decision can lead to a more confident, comfortable retirement.

Call to Action: Still unsure about your timing? Speak with a qualified retirement advisor who can help you evaluate your options and make the best choice for your future.

Grab the your free Brighter Retirement Essentials book today!